Sorry, for some reason i only caught the question part of the message. I viewed the cases, the otterbox 3000 is a great case but it is 8 inches long. I'm looking for something that i can have easily on my side and still be able to do my work with. Something that i can also have on while i'm walking around casually not at work. I looked at all those other cases while i was at the Verizon store earlier and none of them seemed as rugged or as durable as the otterbox. That is why i would like ot stick to my Commuter and then just find a holster to fit. I appreciate your help though!